Monday, October 20, 2014

LTE 10/10: Vote yes on bottle bill question

From The Jamaica Plain Gazette

Given all the controversial issues facing us in the coming election, there is one issue that should be, in the common parlance, a “no-brainer:” a yes vote on Question 2, the Bottle Bill.
The bill would revise the existing one to include bottled water, tea, sports drinks and other beverages, which now most often end up in our city drains, parks and nature centers. We should know. Boston Nature Center volunteers and staff spend countless hours picking up these bottles that have floated down drain pipes and ended up in Canterbury Brook and on the banks of its tributaries. Question 2 would reduce this litter and increase recycling rates.
Currently, even with curbside collection for these kinds of bottles in half our cities and towns, only 23 percent of bottles without deposits are recycled, compared with 80 percent of redeemable bottles.
When the first bottle bill was passed, sports drinks and bottled water were not the popular drinks that they are today. We need to update the bottle bill, so that we can keep our parks, rivers and nature centers clean, and save money in the process. It is indeed a no-brainer.
Julie Brandlen
Anne and Peter Brooke Director
Boston Nature Center
Mattapan
Editor’s Note: The writer is a JP resident.
- See more at: http://jamaicaplaingazette.com/2014/10/10/letter-vote-yes-on-bottle-bill-question/#sthash.5jT1Qmoy.dpuf

10/9: Gov. Patrick says beverage industry associate told him bottle bill expansion would fail because 'we have more money than you'

From State House News Service

Gov. Deval Patrick supports a ballot question expanding the bottle deposit law to water and sports drinks, an idea he has repeatedly filed during his seven-plus years as governor, but which has never cleared the Legislature.
On Thursday, Patrick told a story during a WGBH radio interview that shed some light on the dynamics at work behind the proposal.
Before he became governor, Patrick worked for Coca-Cola. He said that when he filed his bottle bill proposal one year, an old colleague from his days in the industry, but not from Coca-Cola, called him and asked what he was up to.
Patrick said he told him, "I've done some homework. I understand it better."
The governor said the colleague laughed and predicted Patrick would not be successful with his proposal "because we have more money than you do."
Opponents of the ballot question, in a campaign fueled by bottling industry funding, have spent heavily on ads promoting additional consumer costs associated with an expanded bottle bill and touting curbside recycling as a better alternative. They came under fire on Thursday, however, when it was revealed they paid a Tufts professor $7,000 prior to that professor endorsing a study which was critical of the movement to expand deposits to include non-carbonated beverage containers in the commonwealth.
Recent polls show voters are leaning against Question 2, which is on the ballot Nov. 4.

10/10: Yes on 2 will boost recycling



Over 30 years ago, Massachusetts took a big step toward a cleaner environment and controlling litter when it put a five-cent refundable deposit on the most popular beverages at the time: soda and beer. That deposit system has been a huge success for over three decades — 80 percent of bottles and cans with a deposit are recycled, according to the Department of Environmental Protection.

Today, bottled water, sports drinks, iced teas, juices, and other on-the-go beverages are widely available and extremely popular. Just 23 percent of these bottles — bottles without a deposit — are recycled, even with the availability of curbside recycling.

Since these beverages are so often consumed away from home, the bottles wind up in the trash or littering our streets and parks, not in the home recycling bin.

We need to update the Bottle Bill — the most effective recycling tool we have — to cover water bottles and similar on-the-go drinks that weren't on the shelves 30 years ago, so that these beverage containers are recycled just as soda and beer containers are recycled.

When we vote yes to pass Question 2, over 1.25 billion more bottles will be diverted from landfills and will be recycled each year.

In addition to keeping more bottles out of our state's waterways, parks, and streets, Question 2 would establish the Clean Environment Fund, directly sending the unclaimed deposits into a dedicated fund to improve recycling, clean up parks, and fund other environmental projects.

Only a yes vote on Question 2 will remove unclaimed deposits from the commonwealth's general fund and put them into this fund for the environment.

Over 100 organizations, committees, businesses, and elected officials support updating the Bottle Bill, including the Environmental League of Massachusetts, League of Women Voters of Massachusetts, Rep. Mary Keefe (D-Worcester), Shrewsbury Recycles, and the West Boylston Solid Waste Advisory Team.

Corporations that make big profits from selling bottled water, sports drinks, and other similar products are spending millions in out-of-state money to persuade Massachusetts voters the Bottle Bill should not be updated.

Whenever you see empty bottles along I-290 or in Quinsigamond State Park, remember that big beverage companies have poured almost $8 million into Massachusetts to keep it that way. They are more concerned with protecting their profits than protecting our open spaces from litter.

Voting yes on Question 2 will also save cities and towns about $7 million a year now spent for litter collection, trash disposal, and storm drain cleaning. Worcester alone would save almost $200,000 annually. In fact, 209 cities and towns passed resolutions in support of the updated Bottle Bill knowing they would save money.

In his recent endorsement of a yes vote on Question 2, Gov. Patrick said it perfectly: "Yes on 2 will increase recycling, clean up our parks, and save cities and towns money."

The choice is simple: voting yes on Question 2 will save taxpayers money while keeping our beautiful state beautiful. Massachusetts voters who want less litter and more recycling will vote yes on Question 2 on Nov. 4.

Phil Sego is an environmental advocate at the Massachusetts Sierra Club, where he's worked for 12 years on environmental issues. He is also a member of the YES on 2 Coalition to Update the Bottle Bill. 

OPED 10/10: Unwarranted fears were spread about ’82 bottle bill too

From The Boston Globe

THE FIRST Massachusetts bottle bill, back in 1982, was attacked in the same way that Question 2 is now being attacked (“Ads with inaccurate data aid foes of wider bottle law,”Page A1, Oct. 3). It was said of the first bill that it would increase the cost of soda (it did not), that it wouldn’t really reduce litter (it did), and that it would cost the state money (it increased revenues).
We should not be fooled by the ads the bottling companies are airing.
We know that more than two-thirds of redeemable cans are recycled and only about a quarter of non-redeemable ones are.
We know that our parks and nature sanctuaries are filled with litter from these nonredeemable cans and bottles, such as tea, water, and sports drinks.
We know that many towns and cities don’t have curbside recycling.
Let’s pass Question 2.
Margaret Rhodes
Brookline

OPED 10/10: At nature center, they’re sadly downstream of our recycling woes

From The Boston Globe
GIVEN ALL the controversial issues facing us in the coming election, there is one issue that should be a no-brainer: a yes vote on Question 2, the bottle bill. The bill would revise the existing one, to include bottled water, tea, sports drinks, and other beverages, which now often end up in our city drains, parks, and nature centers.
We should know. Volunteers and staff at Mass Audubon’s Boston Nature Center spend countless hours picking up bottles that have floated down storm drain pipes and ended up in Canterbury Brook and the banks of its tributaries. Question 2 would reduce this litter and increase recycling rates.
Currently, even with curbside collection for these kinds of bottles in about half of our cities and towns, only about 23 percent of bottles without deposits are recycled, compared with 80 percent of redeemable bottles.
When the first bottle bill was passed, in 1982, sports drinks and bottled water were not the popular drinks that they are today.
We need to update the bill so that we can keep our parks, rivers, and nature centers clean and save money in the process.
Julie Brandlen
Director
Boston Nature Center

Mattapan

10/9: Professor cited as expert was paid by bottle-law opponents

  • From MetroWest Daily News

  • By Colleen Quinn
    State House News Service 

    Posted Oct. 9, 2014 @ 3:49 pm
    Updated Oct 9, 2014 at 4:01 PM 



    BOSTON -- A Tufts University professor recently cited by bottle bill expansion opponents for his endorsement of an independent study of the proposal's impact was paid $7,000 by the ballot committee fighting Question 2.
    Backers of the ballot question that would add a 5-cent deposit to water bottles, juices, and other drinks are questioning the credibility of the professor, who agreed with a study that concluded the proposal would cost Massachusetts residents nearly $100 million annually.
    Environmentalists from "Stop the Litter - Yes On 2" campaign allege that the professor was paid by opponents to agree with the study.
    Nicole Giambusso, a spokeswoman for the "No On Question 2 - Stop Forced Deposits," acknowledged that economics professor Jeffrey Zabel was compensated by the campaign for his work, and approached to look at the study because of his expertise in environmental economics.
    "When the campaign approached him, he said something to the effect of 'I'm going to do an objective analysis' " Giambusso said.
    According to state campaign finance records, Zabel was paid $7,000 for campaign services by Goddard Gunster Inc., a Washington, D.C.-based public affairs and advertising firm. Goddard Gunster was hired by the No On Question 2 campaign, according to Giambusso.
    Backers of a ballot question to expand the state's 5 cent deposit on carbonated beverages to other types of beverages say it will increase recycling. Opponents of the idea have citied cost concerns over the years as they prevented the proposal from moving through the Legislature.
    Environmentalists say bottles without deposits are thrown away or become litter, and communities bear the burden and costs of cleaning them up. Opponents argue the deposit is an outdated, inefficient method of encouraging recycling, and will cost more than curbside recycling. They say deposits are the wrong approach to boost recycling.
    The study by Northbridge Environmental Management Consultants estimated the cost of operating the expanded deposit program would be $68 million and estimated the state would collect an additional $27 million in unclaimed deposits.
    Opponents of the ballot question issued a press released last Thursday, a day after records show a payment was made to Zabel, highlighting his findings. "I've read Question 2, I've examined the research thoroughly, and I'm here to tell you: Question 2 might sound like a good idea initially, but a different story emerges when you delve into the economic and environmental costs and benefits," Zabel said in the release, which did not mention that Zabel was paid for his work.
    Janet Domenitz, executive director of MASSPIRG, said the No On Question 2 campaign has a credibility problem.
    First, the opponents' campaign said "something that was absolutely a lie" when they aired a television ad stating 90 percent of Massachusetts residents have curbside recycling, Domenitz said. Environmentalists dispute that statistic, and asked the no campaign to pull the ad from the airwaves. State environmental officials also agreed the statistic is too high, and the ad's sponsors recently amended the sourcing in the spot.
    • Now, Domenitz said, the campaign is trying to give credibility to the Northbridge study by highlighting the thoughts of an economics professor who was paid for his work by the ballot committee.
      "It turns out the professor has been paid by the American Beverage Association," Domenitz said, referring to the trade group that is helping financing the opposition campaign. "It is not Halloween yet, I don't know who they think they are trying to trick."
      Domenitz said voters need to know that 80 percent of the containers with the 5 cent deposit get recycled, while only 23 percent without the deposit get recycled.
      Zabel told the News Service that before he looked at the study, he believed the so-called bottle bill was a good policy. "But I was convinced otherwise after reading the report," he saidWednesday.
      "I went in with an objective viewpoint in terms of reviewing their analysis. I think that is the best way to go into these, and I came out with the view that the cost of the expanded bottle bill outweighed the benefits," he said.
      Zabel believes the proposal would likely only increase recycling by 1 percent.
      Zabel said he disagrees with the argument that his views are skewed because he was paid by opponents of the initiative petition. A professor at Tufts for 25 years, he said he has been hired by consulting firms to do peer reviews before, saying it is common practice. He has been paid to conduct research for the federal Environmental Protection Agency and to do peer review research for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
      "People get paid for things all the time. Does that mean they are not credible anymore? Most people get paid to do their jobs," Zabel said.
      Phil Sego, an environmental advocate for the Massachusetts Sierra Club, said the study's authors, Northbridge Environmental, lobby for the beverage industry. Sego called the proclamations by Zabel "ludicrous."
      "I think $7,000 can buy you all kinds of things," Sego said.
      Sego said opponents of the deposit try to scare consumers that if the deposit is added to more drinks, manufacturers will raise prices. In other states with deposits, such as Maine, Michigan and Hawaii, product prices did not go up, according to Sego.
      "This is a scare tactic that they use," Sego said. "Who are you going to trust, Coke, Pepsi and Nestle, or are you going to trust the League of Women Voters?"
      The Massachusetts League of Women Voters supports expanding the bottle deposit law, calling it the "most successful recycling measure in the history of the state," on its website.

9/25: Big money backs state anti-bottle-bill campaign

From The Boston Globe

Big money backs state anti-bottle-bill campaign

Another hefty infusion of cash from the American Beverage Association has increased the war chest of those seeking to block the expansion of the state’s bottle redemption law to nearly $8 million — more than quadruple the amount raised by any other ballot campaign.
The No on Question 2 committee, which has already released advertisements seeking to persuade voters to reject adding bottle deposits to water and sports drinks, this month received $2.3 million from the American Beverage Association as well as more than $100,000 from supermarket companies. Last month, the trade association for nonalcoholic drinks contributed more than $5.2 million to the campaign.
Supporters of the ballot question have raised just $525,000, most of which has come from the Massachusetts Sierra Club and other environmental groups. They said they so far lack enough money to buy TV ads.
“We’re in a busy election cycle and we want to reach as many voters as possible; that includes paid media, direct mail, and grass-roots outreach, among other efforts,” said Nicole Giambusso, a spokeswoman for the committee opposing the expansion of the bottle law.
But supporters of Question 2 — which would apply the 31-year-old nickel deposit that encourages recycling of soda, beer, and malt beverage containers to noncarbonated beverages — say the financial disparity reflects the interests supporting the opposition.
“With each new campaign finance filing, Massachusetts voters can see just how far big beverage companies are willing to go to keep our parks filled with litter from over a billion water bottles, sports drinks, and other beverage containers,” said Janet Domenitz, executive director of the Massachusetts Public Interest Research Group.
On Wednesday, Governor Deval Patrick endorsed Question 2.
— David Abel